Fix N.S.W. Transport!

Sydney's CBD and south-east light rail

The NSW government has decided to construct a light rail service between Circular Quay and the Randwick area. Major work started in October 2015, safely after the NSW state election on 28th March 2015. Under a 2013 plan coyly called Sydney City Centre Access Strategy, George Street was gradually closed between Circular Quay and Haymarket. From 4 October 2015, all George Street buses (including those that use the Anzac Bridge) were forced to divert, many along Elizabeth Street. Eventually, when the track is ready, most Elizabeth Street bus services will be replaced by light rail. Most former George Street passengers will have to change between bus and light rail at Haymarket. Meanwhile, businesses along George Street and their customers will have suffered three years' disruption, dust and noise.

The light rail vehicles will be about 67 metres long (more than five times as long as a standard bus). Unfortunately, they will only have a few more seats than two buses. During peak demand, most light rail passengers will have to stand. Even so there mightn't be enough room to carry the passengers that peak-hour buses currently do every day.

The capacity problem stems from Roads and Maritime Services' refusal to allow more than 15 trams per hour each way, because RMS expects that running any more trams would disrupt cross traffic unacceptably. Obviously, this should have been resolved before the project proceeded.

LIGHT RAIL'S DISADVANTAGES FOR
 PASSENGERS  MOTORISTS
More crowded;
Fewer seats;
Many must change
  bus/tram at
  Haymarket.
Loss of access;
More CBD congestion
  esp. for cross traffic.

LIGHT RAIL'S DISADVANTAGES FOR
 BUSINESSES  RESIDENTS
Construction noise and dust drive customers away;
Loss of parking.
Noise from 4:30 am to after midnight 7 d/w;
Loss of parking;
Loss of trees.

One notable idiocy, announced on 3rd December 2014, was to delete the planned World Square stop as unfeasible. Apparently the 67-metre length of the platform on a sloping street would require disruptive engineering works to comply with disability access requirements. So there'll be no station between Town Hall and Chinatown - a gap of 525 metres. Unsurprisingly, many World Square businesses and Eastern Suburbs residents have expressed opposition to this announcement and/or the whole project. Learn more ...

The obvious way to avoid the problems is to drop the light rail and instead complete the heavy rail from Bondi Junction to about UNSW. Otherwise, worthwhile mitigation of the principal problem (lack of passenger-carrying capacity) could be achieved by having some trams from Kingsford and/or Randwick travel to somewhere other than Devonshire St and George St. Possible destinations which should be considered include Bondi Junction, Kings Cross, St James, Green Square and Redfern/Darlington. No announcement has been made suggesting that the NSW government is evaluating such extensions. Rather, numerous well-meaning but uninformed commentators want the lines extended southward to Coogee, Maroubra, Eastgardens etc. which would exacerbate the shortage of capacity in the CBD.

Following pressure from Randwick Council and elsewhere, the Randwick terminus is moving to High St, which will leave High Cross Park untouched.

A welcome reaction from Randwick Council was a push to save trees around Alison Road by reversing the change of alignment near the racecourse. As noted elsewhere, the total CSELR toll on trees will be many hundred, including Devonshire Street. If you object to motorways because they take trees, you should also object to anything else that takes trees. But the push failed, apparently because the racecourse suddenly decided the trams should be on the opposite side of Alison Road.

Learn more about the issues ...

Sydney Light Rail Action Group website.

Save the Trees and Buses website.

People Unite Surry Hills website with some observations.

Website questioning the proposed Canberra light rail.
...more
...still more.

Video about tree removal.

The NSW Auditor-General's report on the project.

      home             facebook             twitter             email

Fix N.S.W. Transport!